Tampa Convention Center — they get an A+ for hospitality and organization.  They are ready for the hoard of United Methodists.  And the UMC is ready as well.  It is impossible not to be impressed by the pageantry and preparation.  But it is also a little depressing.  I just walked through the Cokesbury and General Agency display areas.  As always, the dog and pony show has been upgraded to elephant and stallion levels.  You cannot believe the mountains of crap that have been produced and stamped with the General Conference logo.  Stewardship be damned.  This is a marketing event, a media circus.

One of the General Agency staff people commented, “A few years ago it was tables and chairs, but now it’s like, ‘If you’re going to get rid of us, we want you to know about everything we do.”  And it shows.  This looks and feels a lot more like a trade show than a religious gathering.  BIG displays, BIG ideas, and BIG money have been lavished on this GC.  Be careful not to ask where the money came from to pay for all this — just consume and enjoy, sipping your water from the official GC2012 water bottle, while resting in your GC2012 hoodie sweatshirt, while leafing through your commemorative GC2012 CEV Bible…  And we justify all this how?

I know, I know, get over myself.  Why do I have to spoil everything?  Could I be any more of a buzz kill?  Did I come here just looking for things to be unhappy about?  You know, I get tired of it myself sometimes.  I want to enter into our denominational celebrations and feel elation and joy.  But it is just my nature to resist and resent the circus-like aspects.  I hunger for authentic opportunities to celebrate the faith with my brothers and sisters.  I cannot wait for the worship and learning opportunities to commence.  But all the consumeristic, self-serving, promotional/trivial junk leaves me cold.

At a time where our credibility and relevancy are front-burner concerns, I wonder if we do ourselves more harm than good investing our time, energy and money in a conference that provides and promotes the same-old, same-old?  Truly, this is a spiritual stewardship issue, and I personally cannot proudly defend the way my church is using its money.  Extravagance and waste are in evidence everywhere I look.  I want to believe we are better than this.  (Yeah, I know, lighten up…)

There is a real integrity in making the mission of the UMC our General Conference theme, but we must guard this integrity by what we say and do.  So far, our restructuring proposals are not proposals for effective disciple-making that equips, empowers and enables our churches and conferences to transform the world; they are all institutional preservation proposals that will allow us to survive for another generation.  If we can somehow shift our attention from maintenance to mission and to truly explore the implications of a church committed to discipleship instead of numbers, this could be a pivotal General Conference.  But like me personally, collectively we need to get over ourselves, and understand this is big, important stuff we are dealing with.  This is more than hats and T-shirts, magnets and coffee-mugs; this is life and death, eternal life big, and we need to act like it.  The world doesn’t need us, it needs God, and we are only relevant and pertinent to the extent that we provide a bridge between God and God’s creation.  The world — and the church — doesn’t need all this “stuff.”  It needs to focus on relationships that help us to become “one with Christ, one with each other, and one in ministry to all the world.”

19 responses to “Impressed & Depressed”

  1. gavoweb Avatar

    Can you bring me back a hoodie? I need a new one. &:~)

  2. John Meunier Avatar
    John Meunier

    Vocabulary nerd: You mean “horde” not “hoard” in the first paragraph. Although maybe you are making a sly theological point about Christians being the gathered collection of God.

    http://grammar.about.com/od/alightersideofwriting/a/hoardhordegloss.htm

    1. Dan R. Dick Avatar
      Dan R. Dick

      Thanks for the catch – I type faster than I think (however, hoard may have been subliminal — Cokesbury looks a lot like the homes of deeply pathological hoarders at the moment.

  3. David Kueker Avatar

    A few years ago I began to think of the General Conference as the gathering of the Sanhedrin. This is, of course, an unfair but perhaps not inaccurate label.

    The potential value of that label isn’t really about the Sanhedrin, but about Jesus or the disciples usage of time in relation to influencing the Sanhedrin.

    Those who are sent have a stewardship to fulfill, but the action is back at home … and they know this. May the spirit of Gamaliel be strong with them…

  4. Cynthia Astle Avatar

    Dan, you’re singing my song. And yes, it does get wearying to keep pointing out where God isn’t at work in our human actions. You’re right that the way to balance this necessary prophetic voice is to sing out about those places where we DO see God’s Holy Spirit acting in human effort. I struggle with the same impulses; it helps me to remember the prophets Jonah and Jeremiah — Jonah so that I don’t pout when people repent and Jeremiah so that I show hope for the future. Not easy, my friend; I’m praying for you.

  5. thoughtfulpastor Avatar

    Reblogged this on thoughtfulpastor and commented:
    I wrote the piece below about General Conference last night and then saw the article below here. Good to know others are troubled with the situation:

    I just skimmed through the advance edition of the Daily Christian Advocate (http://umcmedia.org/gc2012/adca/English/Handbook/Delegates%20Handbook.pdf) that is printed and published daily throughout General Conference. This edition sets the rules for GC, among other things.

    After looking at this labyrinth document, it becomes clearer whey we are grinding to a halt as a denomination. We have surpassed even the most scrupulous of the law-abiding Pharisees of Jesus’ day by our attention to the tiniest detail of law—and the mission of the church, while still there, becomes hard to find and even harder to find enthusiasm for.

    Could it be that our methods, which once gave life, are now so choking us that the Spirit of God no longer has room to play, to touch, to redeem, to set people free from the chains of sin and death?

    I am deep in prayer for all who are there, and am praying for renewal to take place. Renewal never, ever follows the rules, but invites us into Holy Chaos and sends us to our knees in awe.

  6. Wesley White Avatar
    Wesley White

    Struggle? What struggle? Isn’t this just Jesus asking about feasts and festivities trumping mercy?

  7. Logan Garth Swanger Avatar
    Logan Garth Swanger

    Isn’t it any wonder why some of us struggle with cynicism?

    1. Dan R. Dick Avatar
      Dan R. Dick

      Yes, and I need to be careful not to just focus on the negatives. The crass commecialism is only one aspect of the whole experience, but I was overwhelmed by it as I walked through the convention center. We need to be able to point to the ways we invest our time, energy and money and proudly say, “this is how we honor and glorify God!”

Leave a reply to thoughtfulpastor Cancel reply