Methodist(n.) – a proponent of John Wesley’s grace-based faith movement grounded in the three principles of relational evangelism, global missions, and social justice. Ethicist (n.) – a person devoted to the values and moral precepts that guide or govern individuals, a group, or a culture. Methicist (n. extinct) – a person devoted to the values and moral precepts that guide or govern individuals or groups in a culture based on John Wesley’s grace-based faith movement grounded in the three principles of relational evangelism, global missions, and social justice.

Don’t look for this mashup anywhere else, I just made it up. It is a term/concept that keeps tickling my brain every time someone asks me to explain why the United Methodist Church imploded and split. I thought it would be easier and beneficial (for myself) to put my answer(s) in print. Up front I admit my bias and position: those who chose to leave Methodism abandoned the basic precepts of our scripture, our theology, our values, and our communion, i.e., they lost their way and led many astray.

I don’t know how many posts this will take, so I am going to chunk it out to make each read a little more manageable. Once you get me started on this, it is very hard to shut me up. Trust me.

So, today I will list out the key issues of division, misunderstanding, ignorance, or outright rejection. Yes, I understand there is an arrogance in sharing an opinion about any of these things, and I am fine with those who disagree. However, I think I can provide some pretty convincing arguments and examples to back up what I say.

The issues:

  • Respect for the goodness of God’s creation
  • Understanding of the “children of God”
  • Respect for the value of scripture
  • Understanding of grace
  • The conditions of unconditional love
  • Communal identity vs. individual entitlements
  • The unique tenets of Methodist commitment
  • Kenosis
  • Church

Every few days I am going to reflect on one of these topics and explain how I feel each became a dividing wedge in a faith communion that lost its mind, damaged its soul, and broke the hearts of millions of people, providing a “Christian” witness of selfishness, hatred, prejudice, and small-mindedness to our culture and world. We made God look really sad and pathetic to critics of the faith as well as lifelong believers. I wonder if God is amused?

4 responses to “Methicists”

  1. Betty Armstrong Avatar
    Betty Armstrong

    Dan,

    As a member of a strongly reconciling congregation in Austin Texas I look forward to hearing your thoughts on what is happening to all of us. St. John’s has been designated a Lighthouse Church here in town. So we are welcoming a lot of grieving people who couldn’t continue to be the church where they were planted. Perhaps there will be opportunities to share even as we welcome and comfort them.

    Blessings, Betty Armstrong, retired local pastor

    >

  2.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Please NEVER “shut up”

  3.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    In Spiral Dynamics, the red with a blue edge chose to depart from a green with an orange tail and the green chose to regress rather than lead…

  4.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    I suspect Claire Graves might understand these dynamics a bit differently, in a less ‘partisan’ perspective.

Leave a reply to Betty Armstrong Cancel reply