American Exceptionalism. We are better than – not luckier, not more blessed, not more grateful – just better than everyone else in the world. This belief is held by many (too many) people calling themselves Christian in these United States. I say, “calling themselves” because by no objective standard do they meet the definition of a true disciple of Jesus Christ.

Love of neighbor is actually defined as love of stranger, love of foreigner, love of enemy, love of non-related persons in Jesus parable that we label The Good Samaritan. Even this title indicates an acknowledgment that our inherent bigotries, biases, and prejudices are antithetical to the values and teaching of Jesus.

Semitic history is fraught with endless competition between the different groups to establish exceptionalism, so I guess it is anti-Semitic to argue against exceptionalism, but at least for those of us who trace our Christian faith back through its Jewish and Hebrew roots we run into a big problem: Jesus came/was sent to eradicate and destroy such petty and paternalistic notions as racial, ethnic, or geographic exceptionalism. We (defined here as citizens of the United States) are no better than, no more valuable than, no worthier than, no move beloved than any other of God’s precious children.

Any borders that divide us are of human origins, fostered through our sinful and disobedient natures, not through our faith. Oh, certainly faith is used as an excuse – to do all sorts of horrendous and heinous things – but this is a false faith; one that has absolutely nothing to do with God and the Christ. Jesus himself is crystal clear: the measure of our love of God in Christ is how we treat the stranger, the immigrant, the refugee, the asylum seeker. If anything were to make us exceptional it would be how we care for those least like us.

Getting along with people is tricky at the best of times, even with family (remember, Thanksgiving is a week away) so getting along with strangers is always going to be a challenge. But we will fail mightily is our default setting is one of superiority, distrust, contempt, selfishness, and hostility. The only solution is to adopt the counter-cultural Christlike character of humility, compassion, empathy, tolerance, and grace. Beyond that, defining characteristics must include love, kindness, generosity, patience, self-control and the deep desire for peace (all fruit of the Holy Spirit that God alone can grant us). In my book, no one claiming exceptionalism may assume the name “Christian.” Being Christian isn’t what makes us exceptional; being loved by God is, and oh, by the way, God loves billions of people we have never had, and never will have, the opportunity to meet. Those we deport? God loves. Those who go to bed hungry every night? God loves. Those whom we deny health care? God loves. Those we vilify for simply trying to live without fear and dread? God loves. Those we fear so badly that we feel we need guns and security systems for protection? God loves. Even the tiny minority of bad actors who are exploited to make us fearful and hateful, who really are up to no good? God loves.

How long will we live with a scripture teaching us that God IS love before we actually believe it and act like it? Why do so many confuse fear with faith, missing the fact that it is our fear that is exceptional, not our race, creed, or color? Why are the angry, violent, hateful, and hurtful voices so loud that try to redefine a Christianity that has nothing to do with God or Jesus the Christ?

We – all of us – live together on a glorious gift from God for all God’s people, the planet earth. Throughout our history, human beings have gone out of their way to create boundaries and divisions, borders and control, bigotries and competition, but for those of us following the revolutionary teachings of Jesus of Nazareth we seek reconciliation, peace, unity, and hospitality. It may never be a simple choice or decision but each of us has to choose. Are we exceptionally better or exceptionally blessed, exceptionally superior or exceptionally lucky, exceptionally worthy or simply and wonderfully exceptionally loved? And if we are blessed, lucky, and loved shouldn’t that make us exceptionally willing to share?

Leave a Reply